Week 8 review: No bad dances, but no classics either
Week 8 to me was an interesting show in that I don’t think there were any bad dances this week. They all had something to give, but I also think there was nothing particularly standout about it either- it’s definitely been an oddly skewed series. They’re all kind of in that bubbling under category, I’m not sure I’ve seen any routines that will go down in Strictly history.
Also, just getting it out of the way first… Johannes is still messing up his lines when reading off the teleprompter. He’s a dancer… not a natural presenter. Right at the start, he stumbled over mentioning that Delta was dancing with Aljaz. He’d have known Aljaz for years too! Next year I think I’d probably reshuffle him back to the pro lineup and stick Josh upstairs.
First up were Graeme and Lauren with a quickstep to the Happy Days theme- he’s had quite a few early slots the last few weeks. He embraced the performance of it all, but there were several extremely noticeable mistakes in there- he went wrong early on really noticeably and never recovered. The routine felt like it dragged a bit. I think at this moment in time, what’s keeping him safe is the fact that his pro knows how to play to his strengths and how to sell a performance. To me the styling of this dance was odd… the song, the costumes and the set design would all suggest Jive rather than quickstep. It’s a 6 from me and that feels a tad generous. Judges went 6, 7, 7, 7. A bit higher than I’d have gone but nothing too drastic.
Then we had Dani and Nikita with a Paso Doble to a paso-fied version of Everybody Wants to Rule the World… also interesting Will and Dianne appearing on the VT as they were also doing a Paso- feels like it’s been years since the celebs popped up in each other’s VTs. As for Dani herself, this is an interesting one, and if I’m judging JUST the performance, absolutely it’s a 10, some wonderful special effects in there, and I loved the opening with Dani and the flamethrowers but it was all very showy… the actual technique to me looked a bit awkward… I don’t feel we’ve quite reached peak Dani yet, her arm movements at the end looked pretty clunky and her shaping was pretty hit-and-miss… and yes, of course there were the lifts- Craig actually brought illegal lifts up for the first time in goodness knows how many years. She did deliver the drama, she’s a fantastic actress, and all the flashiness of it was great. 7 from me. Judges went 6, 8, 8, 8 for a total of 30… again pretty fair. The judges have been good value tonight and giving proper critiques.
Then we had John and Katya with a Jive, which was… fine- I like his personality when dancing but the actual dance itself was really nothingy. I’m struggling for words on this really- it seemed pretty low energy. Nothing atrocious or anything but I don’t think Jive is a dance that came naturally to him- the difference in energy levels was really apparent when you looked at Katya next to him who was giving it 100% but John just lacked the speed about him. I agree with Anton in that John’s performance level somewhat died towards the end too. It just wasn’t his dance for me. I’m not sure I like watching John in Latin. It’s a 5 from me. Right in the middle- bang-average. Judges went 7, 8, 8, 8 which I think is overly generous - also I’m somewhat tired of how much his sweat gets mentioned.
Then we had Tabby and Mark with a lovely Viennese waltz to Avril Lavigne… unfortunately as good as this dance was, it was bland. Normally I appreciate understated performances, and Viennese waltz is normally a bit of a crowd pleaser, but this one wasn’t really… it was just nice. She’s a very natural dancer, the chemistry is there, technique-wise, there were no notable errors, but I actually think Mark’s choreo was quite dull… and if I was being very picky, I don’t think her fleckerl was all that great, but it’s still the best dance there’s been all night so my score will reflect that. It’s an 8 from me. It was just missing something for a 9 or 10.
Next up we had Cach and Maddie doing a Charleston to Blame It On The Boogie and I must say this was his best dance by a mile. He’s showing quite a bit of personality now, his performance quality is on point, technically he didn’t miss a beat… there are two issues I have with it though. The first is that it wasn’t completely in sync… it wasn’t WILDLY out of sync but it had a few moments… but the other problem I had was that it wasn’t really much of a Charleston… it was more of a Couple’s Choice with a couple of Charleston moves in there… Jenny Thomas (the specialist choreographer) abandoned staying true to the dance style to play to Cach’s strengths. It somewhat paid off because it was a bit of a breakout performance for him but I am really torn on how to score this. I’m hovering around a 7-8 range but I wouldn’t be able to narrow it down to one number I don’t think. However, the judges went 9, 10, 10, 10… sorry but that was wildly overmarked. It may have been one of those that was better in the studio.
Then we had Delta Goodrem and Aljaz (filling in for an unwell Kai) dancing an Argentine Tango… of all the dances for your partner to miss, Argentine Tango is the one you’d least want it to be, because it’s about chemistry. I loved the aesthetic styling of this dance- her posture is incredible- she’s got a really long elegant neck. I actually can’t fault this technically, my main issues with it are 1) I think the music was a bit of a letdown (Missing by Everything but the Girl… now if they’d done just the instrumental Argentine Tango version of the same song, it would’ve been perfect) but more than anything, I just think the chemistry was missing with Aljaz vs Kai, understandably. Aljaz did a very good job stepping in, but Delta and Kai together are much more well matched. It’s an 8 from me. Judges went 9, 9, 8, 9. I’m with Shirley but this score was fair overall.
Then we had Lacey and Vito doing the American Smooth to Have You Met Miss Jones. I thought this dance was FANTASTIC, old school Hollywood glamour, her dress and styling were lovely- it was a wonderful routine and it really was one of the standout dances. What’s that? It wasn’t an American smooth? It was a Foxtrot? That’s really unfortunate… because if this was billed as an American Smooth, it would’ve been top marks, but they danced the wrong style- the routine didn’t meet the brief at all. I think this dance really was a fantastic American Smooth but it wasn’t what it said on the tin which was Foxtrot so I’d have to mark down for that, with a 7. If it’d been listed as American Smooth, an easy 10.
Will and Dianne were next with a Paso… and to be honest, this, like John was just fine this week… I didn’t like the styling of it- Paso should have a bit of balance between sheer masculinity and campness, and I think Will’s was just camp. I also think he needed to straighten his spine out a bit… his posture was pretty weak. You could see him counting the dance too, but what I like with Will is that every week he gives it his all and Dianne is always giving him recognisable choreography for that style. Sometimes that choreo is a bit gimmicky but still recognisable- this week there were no gimmicks but the dance just wasn’t my cup of tea. It’s a 5 for me… it was fine but it’s not something I’d go back and rewatch.
And finally you had Jaime and Carlos with a Charleston- Jaime is still injured so there were no lifts in this Charleston, and do you know what? It didn’t need them. This managed to capture that old school 20s flapper vibe PERFECTLY- she brought so much personality to it! And the swivel was fantastic! It did at times feel a bit careful, but we do have to take injury into account. I really liked the brief solo dance section- that was cool. This to me was a classic Strictly Charleston. I really liked it, and for me, this was a 9. This was the better Charleston tonight by a mile.
As for the dance-off, Will vs Jaime- I was actually quite surprised considering both of them had later performance slots that they landed in the bottom two together. However, the decision based off the dance-off was absolutely a no-brainer. The judges explained their reasons clearly, Jaime made a mistake right in front of Anton, and I think that’s interesting- the same dance can look different from 4 different angles. A mistake might really pop out on Anton’s end that Craig barely notices. But overall, the right result, and I do think we’ve got a decent top 8 for Blackpool where hopefully we get some standout performances.